Obama Classification Reform Effort Fails to Take Hold

An Obama Administration initiative to curb overclassification of national security information that was announced in December 2009 has produced no known results to date.

The Fundamental Classification Guidance Review, which was mandated by President Obama’s executive order 13526 (section 1.9), requires each classifying agency to review all of its existing classification instructions prior to June 2012 and “to identify classified information that no longer requires protection and can be declassified.” While more than a year remains to complete the process, it is already behind schedule.

The Department of Defense, the most prolific classifying agency, failed to produce implementing regulations for the executive order in advance of the December 31, 2010 deadline for doing so set by the President.  As a result, most DoD components have not even started to review their classification guides, of which there are thousands.

Most recently, U.S. Central Command said that it had no records concerning the Fundamental Classification Guidance Review.  “We conducted a thorough and good faith search for responsive information,” CENTCOM told us in a March 28 letter (pdf). “Despite our extensive and careful search for documents pertaining to your request, we were unable to locate responsive information.”

U.S. European Command, on the other hand, said that it had already completed its Fundamental Review. But it concluded that its existing classification practices were already optimal, so no reductions in classification were required!

“The EUCOM Intelligence Office conducted a review as directed by E.O. 13526 for a Fundamental Classification Guidance Review,” EUCOM said (pdf) on January 18.  “No inefficiencies were found during the EUCOM review. No documents were produced during the review therefore, EUCOM reports a no records found in response to your FOIA request.”

Other agencies, including the Department of Energy, the Department of Homeland Security, and the Department of State seem to be taking a more diligent approach to the Fundamental Review, though even in those cases no specific elimination of any current classification instruction is known to have occurred thus far.

Some significant reductions in Obama Administration classification policy have occurred, including dramatic changes in intelligence budget secrecy and nuclear stockpile secrecy.  But these important developments emerged from issue-specific circumstances, and not from systematic classification reform efforts.

Last January, the director of the Information Security Oversight Office wrote to senior agency officials to emphasize the importance of the Fundamental Review and the need for rigorous implementation.

“The scope of this review needs to be systematic, comprehensive, and conducted with thoughtful scrutiny involving detailed data analysis,” wrote ISOO director William J. Bosanko.  But Mr. Bosanko has recently moved on from ISOO, which awaits appointment of a new director.  Meanwhile the Fundamental Review appears stalled and unproductive in much of the executive branch.

No Responses to “Obama Classification Reform Effort Fails to Take Hold”

  1. dustime8 April 12, 2011 at 3:46 PM #

    This is obvious foot dragging by bureaucrats and on the other side of the coin it could be word of mouth from higher up’s to take your sweet time. Either way the machinery is out of sync here and there has to be a reason. Finding reason in politics is like finding the meaning of life.

  2. Bob April 18, 2011 at 1:12 PM #

    In the movie, “Body of Lies”, the Jordanian Intelligence Chief (Hani) said, “Real Intelligence remains a secret forever.”
    The American public actually sleep better at night, not knowing what really happens every day. Classified information is gathered by sources and methods. Revealing the information gathered can inadvertently reveal those sources and methods, rendering them useless. Which, in turn, only makes us more vulnerable to the types of attacks we are trying so desperately to prevent.